Forum
A place to discuss topics/games with other webDiplomacy players.
Page 139 of 160
FirstPreviousNextLast
Chumbles (1380 D)
24 Dec 19 UTC
(+2)
Happy Xmas
Best wishes for the new year and a happy holiday to all; I believe Amby will shortly be arising as Santa follows the course of the new day
2 replies
Open
erikip107 (2543 D)
19 Dec 19 UTC
Rating question
Hi! New to forums and fairly new to this game, I was wondering how the rating system works. I understand generally that we gain points for draws and solos, and lose them for defeats and survivals, but how is it determined how much we gain or lose?
erikip107 (2543 D)
19 Dec 19 UTC
Do WTA games differ from PPSC in this regard (or is it just the points that you use to bet that differs between the two)? Additionally, I was wondering in particular about this game:

https://vdiplomacy.com/hof.php?gameID=40153

This wasn't an unranked game from I can tell, but nobody's ratings moved. Though the 4 of us that drew got the coin things (C points? idk)


Any info would be appreciated, thanks!
Macca573 (1517 D)
19 Dec 19 UTC
(+1)
The "bet" is how many points you pay, these points are put in the "pot".

A game can end in one of three ways:
1. Draw. If this happens, all surviving players split the "pot" equally, taking home their new share of the loot
2. Cancel. If this happens, players receive their "bet" back, and the server pretends like the game never happened.
3. Solo. There are two possibilities for this, depending on the scoring.
WTA: the winner takes all the points in the "pot"
PPSC: the points are split up among the surviving players, based on the amount
of centers they control.

That is how D-points work.

V-points? I got no idea.....
And you'd be lucky to find someone who did. (admins included, it looks super complicated).
Macca573 (1517 D)
19 Dec 19 UTC
(+1)
(that last bit about admins was a joke by the way. I'm sure they know what they're doing)
erikip107 (2543 D)
19 Dec 19 UTC
Ah, ty! The pot makes more sense now.
JohnyD (2012 D)
24 Dec 19 UTC
Another good question is why do I lose vPoints, when I win!?
https://vdiplomacy.com/hof.php?userID=12807 Look at games 39110 and 39187. I've lost 93 rating, while I won both.
Mercy (2131 D)
24 Dec 19 UTC
(+1)
@JohnyD That must surely be a bug.

According to the following pages, you won 7 points in each game. This is pretty standard for winning a 1v1 game. In game 39110 it says for example that you went from a rating of 1084 to a rating of 1091.
https://vdiplomacy.net/hof.php?gameID=39110
https://vdiplomacy.net/hof.php?gameID=39187

However, according to the page you showed, you lost 54 and 39 points respectively. Those numbers don't make any sense. For game 39110 it says for example that you went from a rating of 1084 to a rating of 1030.

Sometimes the bug favored you, though. For instance, according to the following link, you should have lost 7 points in this game.
https://vdiplomacy.net/hof.php?gameID=39249
However, according to your link, you won 46 points.

I'd make a bug report in the ModForum (top right).
tobi1 (1997 D Mod (S))
24 Dec 19 UTC
(+1)
Yes, that was a bug. The rating is now corrected.

Regarding the original topic. A less documented feature of the Rinascimento variant is that it is not regarded / considered as unrated in the vPoint rating. The reason for this is the unbalance of the variant and the impossibility to apply the special algorithm for the D point calculation that is described on the variant page to the vPoint rating.


7 replies
MagicalSand (1726 D)
26 Nov 19 UTC
Lose less points when you replace a player?
Should we really lose as many points when let's say. You replace a player who is in a decent position. Only to upon entering the game automatically start in a terrible position. And then lose 20 points in a game you had 0 chance of surviving in. Should you really lose those 20 points? What If you lost less points when replacing a player to make it less damaging when you start in terrible positions. What you guys think?
9 replies
Open
ingebot (2014 D)
01 Dec 19 UTC
(+1)
The IST province in modern Europe
It appears that there are two IST provinces (Istria and Istanbul). For Istria, that doesn't look like Italy's modern borders, especially as it removes Slovenia's existing coast in today's world.
15 replies
Open
ingebot (2014 D)
03 Dec 19 UTC
My games
What happened to "my games" on the homepage?
2 replies
Open
Lei Saarlainen (1120 D)
03 Dec 19 UTC
transform option in europa renovatio
i want to know if this rule implemented and if yes how to do it ?
1 reply
Open
Macca573 (1517 D)
23 Nov 19 UTC
(+6)
Improving Fog Of War
Fog of war applies to a few maps, classic, 1998, and such; but it seems like a simple add in. How hard would it be to get FoW as a setting rather than variant property? I would think there are many maps and games I would like to try with it, but it's only on a few things. There are also some variants like Rat Wars, that can only be done in FoW. Just wondering if this was a possibility?
10 replies
Open
No one is taking over CDed nations.
No one is taking over civil disordered nations.
22 replies
Open
Macca573 (1517 D)
22 Oct 19 UTC
(+2)
Betrayal
Diplomacy is a game about betrayal, but how can you avoid other players raging at you when you betray them?
8 replies
Open
gopher27 (1606 D Mod)
09 Nov 19 UTC
Was the Munich Agreement a British diplomatic coup in 1938?
Neville Chamberlain died on 11/9/1940. Chamberlain's brother had won the Nobel Prize for Locarno, which has explicitly stated that the UK viewed Germany's Eastern border open for revision and was only committed to defending Germany's Western border. Other than getting Hitler's signature on an agreement that he then violate in less than 6 months, I see no other way that Chamberlain could have gotten a treaty with Poland ratified or instituted peace time conscription in a democratic society.
2 replies
Open
AJManso4 (2318 D)
07 Nov 19 UTC
Ben SC in Rinascimento Variant
As the Ben SC cannot move, however, when it is dislodged can it retreat anywhere? Or is it forced to disband?
3 replies
Open
Arado (1301 D)
08 Nov 19 UTC
vDiplomacy-points scoring
I am still quite new to this website and I am confused on how the scoring works.
2 replies
Open
Flame (1073 D)
07 Nov 19 UTC
DNWC 2020 ?
Is there any ideas about Diplomacy National World Cup in 2020?
I wish Stabbeurfou.org initiate it already!
0 replies
Open
CptMike (1575 D)
20 Aug 19 UTC
FvA championship
Hello,

I propose to launch a FvA championship with 5 players.
130 replies
Open
Strider (1604 D)
29 Oct 19 UTC
Reliability rating penaltys
Discuss
5 replies
Open
Map
Can somebody make this a map?
I asked in the mod forum and nobody has answered me yet.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
https://docs.google.com/drawings/d/1qsAbeu_9T5cpzqAqK2UgULrH56BWqUVtcysYosyokc8/comment
20 replies
Open
Lei Saarlainen (1120 D)
21 Oct 19 UTC
Ready / Non Ready
for be ready what i must read ?
is not a stupid question it can be
1/ i read ready so mean i am ready
2/ i read redy so i must push the button for be ready
4 replies
Open
ingebot (2014 D)
17 Sep 19 UTC
Suggestions for Europa Renovatio to be improved
Firstly, I'd like to congrat and thank Technostar on making an amazing variant. I've just got a few suggestions for improvement:
18 replies
Open
Maps
How do I create maps?
4 replies
Open
BobMcBob (1281 D)
26 Aug 19 UTC
(+1)
Did GvR just get removed?
And why was it a variant in the first place?
7 replies
Open
Mittag (1396 D)
15 Oct 19 UTC
Scoring systems?
The "create new games"-page currently has WTA and PPSC as the two options for scoring systems.
5 replies
Open
diplopoet (739 D)
08 Oct 19 UTC
(+1)
Anonymous games
I've noticed that most of the new games on this website are set to "anonymous". Why is that? Why do the people setting up new games like "anonymous" so much?
16 replies
Open
Frozen Dog (1515 D)
08 Oct 19 UTC
(+1)
What happens if you lose all of your units but still control a non-home supply centre?
I don't mean according to the Calhamer ruleset, but on this site; would you be defeated or live on as a zombie completely at the mercy of others?
4 replies
Open
tobi1 (1997 D Mod (S))
03 Oct 19 UTC
Looking for new moderators
We are looking for new members of the moderator team:
2 replies
Open
tobi1 (1997 D Mod (S))
19 May 19 UTC
(+1)
Game processing paused
We are currently having some problems after another WebDip code merge with some deep changes to the codebase. Game processing has been paused until this is resolved.

Sorry for the inconvenience.
56 replies
Open
The Ambassador (1948 D (B))
28 Sep 19 UTC
Very superstitious
I've got myself into doing a certain thing in my games here and recently changed what I did, for it to go very wrong...
2 replies
Open
Cromig (1409 D)
28 Sep 19 UTC
4 Spots Left on great South America map!
Come join the South America game! https://www.vdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=39913
3 replies
Open
MagicalSand (1726 D)
25 Sep 19 UTC
V Dip Discord?
This is simply a question im curious with. Would it be a good idea if V Dip had a discord server? just curious what people would think about that.
9 replies
Open
Diplomacy Poll
Hello all, I’m trying to make a poll on what people consider to be their favorite parts of diplomacy. I’ll be reading every response and making a chart of what people enjoy the most here, so please help me out and give me some words.
2 replies
Open
Anon (?? D)
24 Sep 19 UTC
Anyone want to take this world game?
I'm playing in World Peace Simulator-2, gameID=39267 , but I'm about to go away and am unsure if I'll be able to input my moves. If you are interested, PM me and I'll tell you what country I'm playing. I don't want to just say it here as the game is anonymous. Then I can use the country switch tool to give it away. Please take a look if you are interested.
Thanks!
1 reply
Open
Page 139 of 160
FirstPreviousNextLast
Back to top